OpenStoopKnow Your Building

Loading building data…

133 Avenue D, Manhattan — Grade F | OpenStoop

133 AVENUE D, Manhattan

Building Health Grade: F (8/100)

Year Built: 1930 · Units: 20

133 Avenue D

Manhattan 10009

F

0

F

0

Health Score

Higher is better. Based on 25 data sources across violations, complaints, permits, sales, and legal records.

High Confidence

This building has critical unresolved issues — proceed with caution

Serious unresolved problems. Consider alternatives or get professional advice before proceeding.

133 Avenue D is a walkup apartment building built in 1930 in Manhattan with 20 residential units. It carries a Grade F health score, with 11 open Class C hazardous violations and Class C violations that have not been corrected among the recorded concerns. Our analysis reviewed 1,390 records across 25 public data sources, benchmarked against similar mid-sized prewar residential buildings in NYC.

Know this building? Does this grade feel right?

Get alerted when this building changes

Create a free account to save buildings to your watchlist and get alerts when grades change.

vs Neighborhood (10009)

1,081 buildings in this zip code

1st

Better than 1% of buildings in 10009

Bottom tier

Avg score: 76

WorstBest in 10009

Alerts

Open Critical Violations

This building has unresolved Class C (immediately hazardous) violations that require urgent repair.

Chronic Habitability Pattern

This flag was detected in our analysis of this building.

Severe Heat/Hot Water Crisis

10+ heat or hot water complaints filed in the past year. Tenants are likely experiencing ongoing outages.

Unresolved Critical Violation

The owner failed to comply with a Class C (immediately hazardous) violation order. This indicates willful neglect.

Rat Activity

This building has repeated rodent inspection failures (3+ in 5 years), indicating a persistent pest problem.

Outstanding Tax Liens

The city has filed tax liens against this property for unpaid taxes or charges. This can indicate financial distress.

Water/Sewer Debt

This property has outstanding water or sewer charges, which can indicate the owner is not keeping up with building expenses.

Compound Distress

This flag was detected in our analysis of this building.

Score Breakdown

Living ConditionsBased on housing violations — things like heat, hot water, pests, mold

57Fair

Building SafetyStructural issues, fire safety, elevator problems, code violations

52Fair

Complaint BurdenHow often residents call 311 or file complaints about this building

29Poor

Management QualityHow quickly the owner fixes problems and maintains the building

81Good

Financial HealthTax liens, water debt, unpaid city charges

46Poor

Legal & EnforcementCity lawsuits and legal actions against the building owner

95Excellent

Maintenance HistoryBoiler, facade, and routine upkeep inspection records

90Excellent

Violations by Year↑ Worsening

Total: 303 violations · Peak: 46 in 2016

Event Activity by Category

Complaints

967

Violations

303

Financial

43

Inspections

42

Permits

17

Compliance

15

Legal

3

Total: 1390 events across 7 categories

Key Statistics

283

Housing Violations→

(41 open)

City-documented problems with living conditions

6.9x neighborhood avg

11

Class C (Hazardous)→

Immediately dangerous conditions requiring urgent repair

4.8x neighborhood avg

18

Building Violations→

Department of Buildings code violations

1.4x avg

586

Building Complaints→

Building-related 311 complaints (housing, safety, maintenance — excludes noise, parking, street)

6.4x neighborhood avg

9

Permits Issued→

Approved construction or renovation work

Near average

1930

Built 96 years ago

↑Improving — 14 violations this year vs 15 last year

Sale History

Ownership changes, mortgages, and financial transactions recorded for this property.

Mar 23, 2015

Agreement — $5,500,000

Recorded

CRFN: 2015000098674

Mar 23, 2015

Assignment

Recorded

CRFN: 2015000098672

Mar 23, 2015

Mortgage — $2,622,583.68

Recorded

CRFN: 2015000098673

Jul 10, 2013

Satisfaction of Mortgage

Recorded

CRFN: 2013000271928

Jun 7, 2012

Assignment

Recorded

CRFN: 2012000222509

Jun 7, 2012

Assignment

Recorded

CRFN: 2012000222508

Mar 15, 2007

Satisfaction of Mortgage

Recorded

CRFN: 2007000139569

Jul 10, 2006

Subordination of Mortgage

Recorded

CRFN: 2006000388783

Jul 10, 2006

Subordination of Mortgage

Recorded

CRFN: 2006000388782

Jul 10, 2006

Mortgage — $1,096,471.06

Recorded

CRFN: 2006000388778

Jul 10, 2006

Tax Lien & Release

Recorded

CRFN: 2006000388781

Jul 10, 2006

Assignment

Recorded

CRFN: 2006000388777

Jun 28, 2005

ASSTO

Recorded

CRFN: 2005000368597

May 24, 2005

ASSTO

Recorded

CRFN: 2005000301935

May 24, 2005

Mortgage — $175,567.5

Recorded

CRFN: 2005000301936

May 24, 2005

Easement

Recorded

CRFN: 2005000301934

Oct 11, 2002

Assignment

Recorded

Oct 11, 2002

Agreement

Recorded

Dec 14, 1998

Assignment

Recorded

Dec 14, 1998

Mortgage — $525,000

Recorded

Dec 7, 1998

Satisfaction of Mortgage

Recorded

Oct 6, 1998

Satisfaction of Mortgage

Recorded

Jul 10, 1998

PAT

Recorded

Jul 10, 1998

Deed Transfer

Recorded

Jul 10, 1998

Satisfaction of Mortgage

Recorded

Jul 10, 1998

Mortgage — $147,000

Recorded

Aug 3, 1994

Mortgage — $95,000

Recorded

Aug 20, 1985

Mortgage — $50,000

Recorded

Date unknown

Mortgage

Recorded

Date unknown

Deed Transfer

Recorded

Tax Liens

Outstanding debts owed to the city. Tax liens can indicate the owner is financially struggling to maintain the property.

May 1, 2025

Water/Sewer Debt

Cycle: 10 Day Notice

Tax Class Code: 2

Building Class: C7

Water Debt Only: Yes

Apr 1, 2025

Water/Sewer Debt

Cycle: 30 Day Notice

Tax Class Code: 2

Building Class: C7

Water Debt Only: Yes

Mar 1, 2025

Water/Sewer Debt

Cycle: 60 Day Notice

Tax Class Code: 2

Building Class: C7

Water Debt Only: Yes

Feb 1, 2025

Water/Sewer Debt

Cycle: 90 Day Notice

Tax Class Code: 2

Building Class: C7

Water Debt Only: Yes

Litigation History

Legal actions taken by the city against this building's owner for failure to maintain safe conditions.

Aug 18, 2021

Tenant Action — 133 AVENUE D LLC,HH PROPERTY MANAGEMENT SERVICES ET AL

PENDING

Case Type: Tenant Action

Case Status: CLOSED

Judgment: NO

Case Opened: Aug 18, 2021

Feb 21, 2017

Heat and Hot Water — 133 AVENUE D MANAGER, LLC,ERIC NELSON

CLOSED

Case Type: Heat and Hot Water

Case Status: CLOSED

Judgment: NO

Case Opened: Feb 21, 2017

Jan 13, 2009

Heat and Hot Water — HARRY WALLACE,JAMES SIMERMEYER,RED MAN TAKES IT BACK

CLOSED

Case Type: Heat and Hot Water

Case Status: CLOSED

Judgment: NO

Case Opened: Jan 13, 2009

Complete record of violations, complaints, permits, and other events for this building, newest first.

High Priority (4)

Complaint

Mar 27, 2026• 1 month ago

CLOSE

UNSANITARY CONDITION — MOLD [EMERGENCY] (Apt 12)

Type: EMERGENCY

Apartment: 12

Space Type: BATHROOM

Unit Type: APARTMENT

Complaint Status: CLOSE

Problem Status: CLOSE

Received Date: Feb 26, 2026

Resolution: HPD attempted to conduct an inspection in response to this complaint, but was unable to complete the inspection. Please submit a new service request with 311 if the condition still exists. For more information on the reason why HPD was unable to insp

Complaint

Mar 26, 2026• 1 month ago

CLOSE

DOOR/WINDOW — DOOR [EMERGENCY] (Apt 10)

Type: EMERGENCY

Apartment: 10

Space Type: LOBBY

Unit Type: PUBLIC AREA

Complaint Status: CLOSE

Problem Status: CLOSE

Received Date: Sep 18, 2025

Resolution: HPD conducted an inspection of this complaint. The conditions observed by the inspector did not violate the housing laws enforced by HPD. The complaint has been closed.

Complaint

Mar 23, 2026• 1 month ago

CLOSE

DOOR/WINDOW — DOOR [EMERGENCY] (Apt 10)

Type: EMERGENCY

Apartment: 10

Space Type: LOBBY

Unit Type: PUBLIC AREA

Complaint Status: CLOSE

Problem Status: CLOSE

Received Date: Sep 19, 2025

Resolution: HPD called the telephone number on file for this complaint. Someone at that number indicated that the condition was corrected. The complaint has been closed. Please submit a new service request with 311 if the condition still exists.

Complaint

Mar 23, 2026• 1 month ago

CLOSE

DOOR/WINDOW — DOOR [EMERGENCY] (Apt 10)

Type: EMERGENCY

Apartment: 10

Space Type: BUILDING ENTRANCE

Unit Type: PUBLIC AREA

Complaint Status: CLOSE

Problem Status: CLOSE

Received Date: Sep 18, 2025

Resolution: HPD called the telephone number on file for this complaint. Someone at that number indicated that the condition was corrected. The complaint has been closed. Please submit a new service request with 311 if the condition still exists.

Informational (1)

Tax Record

Jan 1, 2027• Today

Assessed

133 AVENUE D, LLC

Year Built: 1,930

Building Class: C7

Gross Area: 14,588 sqft

Units: 22

Stories: 6

Zoning: R8A

Assessed Value: $1,355,400

Market Value: $3,012,000

Other Events (15)

311 Complaint

May 8, 2026• 3 days ago

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and observed no criminal violation upon their arrival. If the problem persists, please contact 311 to create another complaint. If possib

Closed Date: May 8, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

May 3, 2026• 8 days ago

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and with the information available observed no evidence of a criminal violation at that time. If the problem persists, please contact 311

Closed Date: May 3, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

May 3, 2026• 8 days ago

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and with the information available observed no evidence of a criminal violation at that time. If the problem persists, please contact 311

Closed Date: May 3, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

May 3, 2026• 8 days ago

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and with the information available observed no evidence of a criminal violation at that time. If the problem persists, please contact 311

Closed Date: May 3, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

Apr 21, 2026• 20 days ago

CLOSED

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and with the information available observed no evidence of a criminal violation at that time. If the problem persists, please contact 311

Closed Date: Apr 21, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

Apr 14, 2026• 27 days ago

CLOSED

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and with the information available observed no evidence of a criminal violation at that time. If the problem persists, please contact 311

Closed Date: Apr 14, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

Inspection

Apr 9, 2026• 1 month ago

Failed for Rat Activity and Other Reason

Initial (Job PC8694560)

Type: Initial

Result: Failed for Rat Activity and Other Reason

Job: PC8694560

Approved: Apr 10, 2026

311 Complaint

Apr 5, 2026• 1 month ago

CLOSED

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and their investigation determined that no criminal violation existed. The condition was corrected without the need to issue a summons or

Closed Date: Apr 5, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

Apr 5, 2026• 1 month ago

CLOSED

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and with the information available observed no evidence of a criminal violation at that time. If the problem persists, please contact 311

Closed Date: Apr 5, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

Mar 15, 2026• 1 month ago

CLOSED

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and their investigation determined that no criminal violation existed. The condition was corrected without the need to issue a summons or

Closed Date: Mar 15, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

Mar 15, 2026• 1 month ago

CLOSED

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and their investigation determined that no criminal violation existed. The condition was corrected without the need to issue a summons or

Closed Date: Mar 15, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

Mar 15, 2026• 1 month ago

CLOSED

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and their investigation determined that no criminal violation existed. The condition was corrected without the need to issue a summons or

Closed Date: Mar 15, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

Mar 15, 2026• 1 month ago

CLOSED

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and their investigation determined that no criminal violation existed. The condition was corrected without the need to issue a summons or

Closed Date: Mar 15, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

Mar 10, 2026• 2 months ago

CLOSED

Loud Music/Party

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Music/Party

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and observed no criminal violation upon their arrival. If the problem persists, please contact 311 to create another complaint. If possib

Closed Date: Mar 9, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

311 Complaint

Mar 8, 2026• 2 months ago

CLOSED

Loud Talking

Complaint Type: Noise - Residential

Descriptor: Loud Talking

Resolution Description: The New York City Police Department responded to the complaint and with the information available observed no evidence of a criminal violation at that time. If the problem persists, please contact 311

Closed Date: Mar 8, 2026

Agency: New York City Police Department

Location Type: Residential Building/House

Property Details

Year Built

1930

Total Units

22

Residential Units

20

Building Class

C7

Location

BBL

1003790037

Zipcode

10009

Location

Open in Google Maps ↗

Property Owner

Owner information requires a free account

Sign up to view property owner details and portfolio analysis.

This report is an informational tool based on publicly available government records and does not constitute a “consumer report” under the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Building grades are editorial opinions and should not be used as the sole basis for housing, lending, or employment decisions. Data sourced from HPD, DOB, DOF, ECB, FDNY, 311, and other NYC agencies. Report errors to data@openstoop.com. See our Terms and Privacy Policy.